Tired of that same-old same-old mantel display? Ready to give your fireplace mantel a fresh look for fall? At Nell Hill’s, we love to inspire customers to mix their own decorating treasures with killer seasonal accents to give their mantels a dynamic new look. We have created three beautiful fall mantel treatments to get your creative juices flowing. 

Before: The Bare Bones

Here’s our blank canvas, the stripped down fireplace in the Abbey Steps room at Nell Hill’s Briarcliff.  This lovely stone fireplace surround is just itching for the colors, textures and icons of fall.


Look 1: A Frolicking Fall Hunt

Maybe I should have been born in England a few centuries ago because I love, love, love British hunting imagery and always look for inventive ways I can weave them into my interior designs. This richly layered mantel succeeds in celebrating fall while also imparting the thrill of the hunt.   Here’s a step-by-step look at how we created this design:

What’s a fall hearth without a cheery fire? We started our display with bundles a white birch logs. Don’t set a match to these beauties – position them for your display, then swap them out for firewood when you’re ready to light your fire.

To establish the theme of this mantel display, we picked some big statement art. Dan and I used to have a beagle, so my heart swelled up when I saw this whimsical painting, which I think accurately captures the unbridled energy and goofy sense of humor of this passel of hunting hounds.  With the painting in place, we started to build our display using tattered old vanilla colored books as risers on either side of the mantel.

Next we topped the piles of books with twin white wooden lanterns. This line of lanterns is a perennial favorite of mine because they are so fresh and clean, and amazingly versatile for decorating. We have carried them at Nell Hill’s for several years, in a variety of sizes, and they just fly out the door. While I use mine in my decorating year round, they are a perfect pick for fall.

If you’re not a fan of lanterns, you could use any number of decorative pieces instead. How about matching ginger jars, pillar candlesticks or concrete finials? Use your imagination!

With the basic structure of the design in place, it’s time to bring on the fall.  We used a variety of fall picks and sprays on this mantel, tucking them in behind the lanterns and books. For a more dramatic overall display, let your faux foliage climb up toward the ceiling. If the branches won’t stay up by themselves, use a fallen stick as a support, first securing it to the wall. The secret to getting a richly layered look with your greenery is to intertwine several pieces and twist the stems so they look organic, not freshly plucked from a box.

For a playful finishing touch, we put a pheasant figurine right at the foot of the pack of dogs, who look as though they are about to leap off the canvas to chase the bird. You just can’t beat whimsy!


Look 2: Golden Age

This lovely mantel is stately and intricate, yet surprisingly clean. You won’t believe how simple it was to construct. Here’s how we did it:

Remember that stack of aged, creamy vanilla books we used as risers in the first mantel? Well, they’re back again in this lovely arrangement. Books make great risers because they add texture and monochromatic color. This time they are stacked neatly on either side of a gorgeous mirror framed in gold. Love this mirror!

Brass is in again, and I’m thrilled. I really like its warm, soft glow. It offers the perfect tone for fall and holiday decorating, when you want soft luster and subtle shine. These statuesque matching lamps, which reach so high, introduce lots of drama to our display and act as perfect book ends, holding everything together.

Layering artwork is a great way to decorate a mantel. For a visually arresting display in minutes, just overlap a few pieces of artwork in dissimilar shapes. Notice how each piece we picked is unique, yet works perfectly with the others to create a unified effect?

This mantel display is so neutral you could leave it up all year long, just switching out a bit of greenery to freshen it up for each season. To tweak it for fall, we simply tucked in a few pretty autumn picks. How easy was that? In seconds, we added lots of texture, color and interest.


Look 3: English Men’s Club

Fall lends itself well to masculine displays, rich in menswear fabrics and accents in yummy shades of brown, red and green. Our third mantel display is a lighter, brighter take on a traditional English men’s club look, with a masculine bent that is equally appealing to the fairer sex. These armless chairs, upholstered in a traditional plaid, set the tone. I really like the playful pillows, don’t you?

Instead of featuring one large piece of artwork above the mantel, we hung a small hunting trophy then topped it with a smaller piece of framed artwork. It’s not the kind of arrangement you see over a lot of mantels, is it? That’s why it’s a perfect pick for Nell Hill’s: we love to catch people by surprise.

This asymmetrical arrangement uses a wild assortment of fall foliage. I like it when the branches climb and twist about, just like they do in nature, stretching toward the ceiling and cascading over the edge of the mantel. The pair of hurricane lamps on either side of the mantel provides a great visual boundary, hemming in the intricate tableau.

If you look closely, you can see that the florals are anchored in a stack of beautiful iron planters, finished in a weathered patina that adds to the natural beauty of the grouping. The books underscore the traditional ambiance of the display and interject a bit of color.

Even though the display is asymmetrical, it is balanced. For example, the stack of iron planters on the left side of the mantel adds visual weight to offset the stack on the right side. There is a lot going on in this display, so we wanted to break up the layers with a bit of sparkle. A few mercury glass pumpkins did just the trick. It’s a tiny addition but has a big impact.


Next week …I’ll show you how to create three unique fall looks using three of my favorite fall decorating tools. You’ll be inspired!

P.S. Don’t miss a bit of Nell Hill’s news – stay up to date on my favorite finds, new arrivals at the stores and all our special events by checking the Nell Hill’s Facebook page every day. You don’t have to have a Facebook page yourself to look in on the fun, but if you’re already on Facebook, “like” us today!

Want to receive the latest blog posting
in your email inbox every week?
Click here to sign up.

20 Responses to “Fall Mantel Makeover: 3 Looks You’ll Love”

  1. Sharon Warren Says:

    Wow! I can’t wait to strip off my mantel and get started! Fall weather comes later here in Texas, but I am ready for the look of Fall inside. Thanks for inspiring us with very do-able ideas.

  2. Brenda Says:

    I was in your store a week ago and was immediatley attracted to the beautiful mantel with the deer. I sent my daughter to the car to get the camera; I HAD to have a photo of that arrangement, and now, here it is on your blog! Love it.

  3. Helene Says:

    Gorgeous! I love the third one best, but sans the deer head. It’s very cozy and interesting. Thanks always for your inspiration.

  4. JoAnn Collier Says:

    I’ve been looking for small lanterns much like the white ones in your design. I’d appreciate knowing how much they are. I look forward to your blog each week.

  5. JoAnn Collier Says:

    I’d like to know the price of the white lanterns in a small size. I saw you use them on windows once and would like to do that. Thanks for all of the great ideas!

  6. Lisa Fernandez Says:

    Oh my Gosh. I just took everything off my mantle the minute I saw and read your post. How do you do it? Mary Carol, your ideas are so wonderful and beautiful. Thank you. Gonna try something new now.

  7. Lisa Sontag Kissee Says:

    Do you sell the birch logs?

  8. Virginia Akins Says:

    I do indeed love the fall mantles and I love Mary Carol for the pleasure she brings me. I am moving in six weeks to a condominium where I will no longer have a mantle, but I hope I can translate some of the ideas to a table or shelf. Virginia Akins 84

  9. Mary Carol Says:

    JoAnn—The small white lanterns are available in the stores or online. The price is $19.95 each.

  10. Mary Carol Says:

    Hi Lisa–The birch logs are available at the Briarcliff store—$15.00 for a bundle of 5. Call 877-746-4320 for more details.

  11. Karen Radley Says:

    Finally…a use for the stuffed pheasant my husband has that I was never crazy about!! After seeing your blog, I dug it out and love it!! Thank you for your great ideas!!!!

  12. Jerry Ballard Says:

    Thanks once again for helping me Fall up my look….Won’t be long before we will gear up for Xmas, putting my nose into your two Xmas books for inspiration! Jerry

  13. natalie Says:

    do you have any suggestions for if you have a large television on the fireplace mantel?

  14. Annette Adams Says:

    Love the deer mantle. You are so creative. I hope I’ll be able to get to Atchison again before long (from SW MO).

  15. Linda Says:

    So many different looks, it’s easy to get carried away and want to do more. Love the look the different looks.

  16. Janet Appleby Says:

    Thanks so much for the How to Decorate a Mantel. I was stumped but your ideas really help!!!!
    Thanks again, Janet Appleby

  17. Robin Frank -- Vision Interiors Says:

    Hi all …. Picture this ….. Sitting in bed with my cup of tea …. Bowl of mixed nuts in my funky pjs …. And your Christmas book from 2002 … Looking for some inspiration for my living room mantle for the holidays . Have to tell you it’s just a terrific Christmas book !!! The photos and ideas are SOO currant and still after 12 years the book I tell my ” people ” to use . Girls … Get this book . Actually both of your holiday books are super … ! the idea about cutting a board for the top of mantle to nail or wire your greens to … Bingo !!! So simple and I needed just that solution so I don’t injure my woodwork . See you at your Christmas tour !!! And another thank you for the best Christmas books in my collection !

  18. search Says:

    Excellent blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
    I’m hoping to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything.

    Would you recommend starting with a free platform like
    Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m totally confused ..

    Any suggestions? Cheers!

  19. Sherry Says:

    Sexy stockings can be wonderful for a woman’s self esteem
    and make her feel like she is the sexiest woman on the planet.
    The soft and silky fabric from which it is made can offer a sensuous feel to the wearer and also
    to those who touch it. For example, white stockings are the type that
    can go with just about any kind of clothing.

Leave a Reply